Hello, Readers. Happy Notebook anniversary. Thanks to Lincee at www.ihategreenbeans.com, you have a bonus post from both of us this week, albeit a partially recycled one.
Ten years. Yes.
It’s been ten years since Ryan went from a Gosling to a full-blown
Goose. It’s hard for me to believe that
the pinnacle of chick movies, The Notebook, is ten years old. It’s even harder for me to believe that I’m
sitting here in my precious free time writing about it.
LOOK, ALLIE IS STILL CHEATING ON HER FIANCE. |
In my experience women fall into three
categories when it comes to this movie.
They are as follows:
1.
The
Notebook is the most romantic story ever.
I cry sweet yet sad tears of joy each time I see Noah and Allie's undying
love (notwithstanding the fact that she cheats on her doting fiancé).
2.
Ryan
Gosling is hot and I’ve seen the movie but don’t really care for it. (This is the minority view)
3.
I
haven’t seen The Notebook because I’ve been busy practicing my softball skills
. . . with my girlfriend.
As with any Nicholas Sparks’ story, it’s
horribly sappy, marginally believable, and features a female lead perfect for
Rachel McAdams. There are lots of water-based metaphors and a pathological devotion to the premise that there's truly only one man for every woman; particularly women who look like Rachel McAdams.
Incidentally, Mrs. Some Guy looks a bit like Rachel McAdams. Maybe I'm into this movie more than I'd like to admit. Annnyyyhooo. . .
Back to the movie.
After a long run around Town Lake (now Lady
Bird Lake) one innocuous 2011 afternoon I sat drinking water in my house
flipping aimlessly around the channels.
I’m not the kind of guy who sits and watches Sportscenter for an entire
weekend, so the boredom brought on by the realization that I pay $200.00 per
month for 1800 channels of nothing was beginning to migrate toward anger. Lo and behold, I happened upon the beginning
scene of The Notebook. Admittedly curious, I hit the record button and
decided to watch it.
After watching it from start to finish. I
called up my good friend and, unbeknownst to me at the time, dyed-in-the-wool
Notebook believer, Lincee Ray.
LR:
What are you doing?
DP:
I’m going to write a review of The Notebook.
LR:
……
DP:
I said, I’m going to write a review of The Notebook.
And that’s now it started. Below is a redacted portion of my April 2011
post entitled I Drink from the Holy Grail. Click on over to Lincee’s rebuttal after you get done with my
review. Enjoy.
(Insert blurry fade out and weird
flashback music)
The Notebook Reloaded
Ideas juggling, I finished my run and
came home to enjoy a cool shower and a giant glass of water. I read a little,
opened some mail, checked some things online, and turned on the television.
Flipping around, I eventually noticed the title of a movie I had heard a lot
about but had never seen.
My inspiration peaked and I knew I had
the subject of my next blog. Yes, Readers, I had come full circle from down in
the dumps to up in the clouds and I decided right then and there to watch from
start to finish with an open mind the Holy Grail of all chick movies. I would
review The Notebook.
Disclaimer: Look, I realize that it’s my
job here to keep you entertained. Sometimes that involves blatant pandering to
the audience and sometimes it involves me just saying “f*ck it” and writing
what I want. I realize that the movie is one that evokes a lot of emotions in
women. In fact, after tipping my hand and telling a couple of my female friends
about my intent to write about it this week, one of them actually became visibly
annoyed at the fact that I might attempt to slaughter the movie, which in her
mind anyway, would lead to the utter destruction of true love itself. If you’re
in the same camp, never fear, I’m certain Lincee Ray at www.ihategreenbeans.com
will resurrect whatever I tear down.
For those of you who have never seen the
2004 movie—I’m probably speaking to my male readers here—it’s a story set in
the 1940’s that focuses around a lumber yard worker named Noah Calhoun and a
jobless rich girl named Allie Hamilton. The narration takes place in the
present day at an old folks home where an old man reads the love story to a
forgetful old woman. We soon learn that the old folks are, in fact, Noah and
Allie in the waning years of their lives.
Noah reads to Allie in hopes that her
dementia will subside long enough for a moment of clarity so he can have her
again, if not for just a few minutes. The entire thing is based on the book by
Nicholas Sparks. Normally, I prefer a book over a movie, but I didn’t read it
in this case. I have no opinion on what type of writer he is, nor do I care for
purposes of this post. This one is about the movie.
The movie begins with a soft music and
some guy rowing on a lake at sunrise while some old broad looks knowingly out
the window as if she was trying to remember where she’d seen geese before. I
was already bored stiff.
The guy from the Rockford Files comes
into her room at the old folks’ home and offers to read to her but the cranky
old lady refuses. Frankly, I would have wished her a good day, told her to
enjoy her applesauce and water from a plastic cup and bendy straw and left to
go play shuffle board on the quad in hopes of hooking up with a lucent
sixty-something for one last roll in the hay.
Regardless, Jim Rockford ignores her
bitching and begins to read to her about a guy named Noah and a girl named
Allie as we flash back to the early ‘40’s before Pearl Harbor was bombed.
Noah is played by Ryan Gosling. He’s
basically a blonde version of Keanu Reeves when it comes to his range as an
actor. He’s wooden, expressionless, and boring. However, he dresses like Brad
Pitt, apparently works in a lumberyard, and immediately wants to have sex with
Allie when he sees her. The guy who plays “E” on Entourage is his best buddy
and despite also dressing like Brad Pitt, he’s basically “E” in The Notebook.
He tells Noah that Allie and her hoity toity friends are out of his league.
Allie is played by Rachel McAdams
who—with the exception of that horrible psycho on a plane movie—plays the same
character in every movie, including Wedding Crashers. She’s pretty, virginal
but not innocent, and was properly cast. They could have picked someone with
bigger cans, but hey, she’ll do. Allie is happy, on summer vacation in
Seabrook, South Carolina, and free of responsibility. Ignoring the fact that
rich, spoiled girls can never be made whole by the man they marry, Noah decides
to c*ck block her date and ask her out.
Noah butts into Allie’s date and Allie’s
date sits there like a pansy in a flowerbed despite his date being openly hit
on by Noah. Perhaps her date was bored with him as well. At any rate, Noah
climbs the Ferris wheel where Allie and her date are riding and proceeds to
hang from the ride one handed until she agrees to go out with him.
Whatever. If I had been Allie’s date Noah
would have been forced to swallow his Brad Pitt hat long before the stunt on
the Ferris wheel. Also, if Allie had agreed to go on a date with him while I
was shelling out cash for carnival rides and Ferris wheels, she would have been
walking her romantic ass all the way home. Romantic moment or not, dance with
the one who brought you, Allie. Trolling for men while you’re on a date is not
cool; especially in front of your date.
In a very Danny and Sandy-esque fashion,
Noah and Allie proceed to gallivant around Seabrook for the entire summer.
Despite having a back breaking job in the lumber yard and apparently no money,
Noah manages to find time for daytime walks, bike rides, and picnics as he and
Allie play a perpetual game of grabass until we learn from Jim Rockford that
they fell madly in love. The old lady remains cranky but interested. She
bitches some more at James Garner as the stereotypical overweight black nurse
enters to give him his medicine before he continues reading. He should have
reminded her that Silence is Golden. Either that or he could have reminded her
that Duct Tape is Silver. She finally shuts up, preferring golden silence to
silver duct tape and he continues reading.
We meet Noah’s affable father played by
Sam Shepard, a real life Pulitzer Prize winner, and he makes Allie some
pancakes while recounting embarrassing stories about Noah’s speech problem. At
least we had a frame of reference for his lack of personality, I thought.
Eventually, Allie’s rich parents come
from Atlanta to retrieve their daughter and discover that she’s dating some
poor lumberyard worker who dresses like Brad Pitt and acts like Keanu Reeves.
Dad and his weird mustache don’t care too much but her domineering, judgey
mother does and she and Noah’s plans at happiness are destined to be thwarted.
We later learn that mom fell in love with
some guy from the lumber yard but married dad because—all things considered—he
was a nice enough guy in spite of his weird mustache and was dripping with
cash. Frankly, that scenario was the most believable in the movie. I found her
hatred of Noah and her assertion of him as “trash” to be inconsistent with her character.
She fell in love with a poor lumber yard guy and ditched the guy for cash; a
move she apparently made peace with but regretted for a lifetime. Calling Noah
“trash” diminishes the validity of that relationship and her belief in the true
love that this whole thing is supposed to be about—in my mind anyway. Allie has
family money and is free to pursue her heart. I have no idea why her mother
wouldn’t support that. Perhaps it’s because the book was written by a man. It
seems that the father should have been the one with the problem and not the
mother. Annnyyyyhoooo . . .
Noah takes Ali to a dilapidated
plantation home called Windsor Mansion and exposes her to the dangers of
unstable ceilings and flammable, brittle wood. He tells her of his dream of restoring
the place if only he had the money to do it. Then they stand across from each
other and undress before “E” sounds the alarm that Allie’s parents are back in
town. Dude. He put up with bike rides, picnics, and flowers all summer and
didn’t get any? I began to see why this movie was so sad.
Noah and Allie eventually fight and
regretfully break up before her parents haul her spoiled, rich ass back to her
mansion in Atlanta. Noah broods a bunch and eventually enlists in the army
after hearing about the Pearl Harbor attack. How romantic.
Despite undoubtedly being stripped of all his belongings and identity and being shipped off to basic training until eventually ending up on a packed warship and traveling overseas to be placed in the gun sights of angry Aryans vying for world domination and watching “E” from Entourage die on the battlefield, Noah manages to write (and mail) Allie one pristinely penned love letter per day for 365 days. After no response for a year, his pen gives up—but alas, his heart does not. Come on. I laughed to myself at the thought of Noah having the wrong zip code or house number. We eventually learn that her lumber yard-whoring mother has been intercepting all of them.
Despite undoubtedly being stripped of all his belongings and identity and being shipped off to basic training until eventually ending up on a packed warship and traveling overseas to be placed in the gun sights of angry Aryans vying for world domination and watching “E” from Entourage die on the battlefield, Noah manages to write (and mail) Allie one pristinely penned love letter per day for 365 days. After no response for a year, his pen gives up—but alas, his heart does not. Come on. I laughed to myself at the thought of Noah having the wrong zip code or house number. We eventually learn that her lumber yard-whoring mother has been intercepting all of them.
While Noah is dodging shrapnel, killing
Germans, and watching his best friend die, Alli poontangs around the Atlanta
social scene with Lon Hammond, a rich guy she met while pretending to volunteer
at some place for wounded soldiers. She loves Noah so much that—get this--she
boozes it up with the rich folks at fancy galas and eventually gets engaged to
Lon Hammond and his money. True love, my ass.
Noah returns home to Atlanta and sees
Alli poontanging around with an engagement ring on her finger. Heartbroken, he
returns to Seabrook where his dad fortuitously tells him that he’s sold his
house so that Noah can buy and renovate the Windsor Mansion. His dad kicks the
bucket unexplainably and Noah miraculously and singlehandedly renovates the
entire plantation into a perfectly finished and manicured piece of artwork in
less time than it takes him to grow a beard and appear Amish despite having
limited funds and a new war-widowed girlfriend who undoubtedly insisted on
picking out the colors for the walls, drapery, and all of the bedding.
All by himself? Hell, the guy didn’t even
ask a contractor for a rough estimate. I asked a guy for a rough estimate once.
He kicked me in the balls and then quoted me the price. I’ll be here all week,
folks.
Noah even manages to include a furniture
shop for himself and a painting studio for Allie complete with the symbolic
blank canvas awaiting her return. I assumed the canvas symbolized Gosling’s
absence of depth rather than Noah’s undying desire for a blank future with
Allie.
While getting her ass kissed in her
wedding dress, Allie sees Noah’s picture in the paper next to his high dollar
house and faints because she believes he is now Amish. She bathes in her veil
and eventually meets her rich, understanding, good looking, tolerant,
well-mannered, doting, successful, non-possessive, supportive, giant
ring-buying, sensitive fiancé at his office where he happily takes a few
moments away from earning a living so she can have the finest things to which
she’s become accustomed in order tell him that she’s going to Seabrook to
poontang around there for a bit. Incredibly, the guy agrees. Bull. Sh*t.
Allie fills the car her fiancé bought her
with gas purchased by money he gave her and heads to Seabrook in search of
Noah. She arrives at the new house and after faking like she’s not there to
sleep with him she and Noah have a rekindling of sorts as he respectfully
recognizes her pending nuptials and opts for a friendship instead. Sparing her
the details of his arduous battlefield missive writing, he instead throws her
in a rowboat and takes her to see a flock of digitally created geese in a swamp
and pretends like they are romantic symbols of their love rather than the
angry, noisy, disease carrying fowl that they really are. Allie sits there in
her sun dress in amazement as Noah overcomes his sore, pre-arthritic joints and
his post traumatic stress disorder so he can transport her spoiled ungrateful
ass across the lake. Meanwhile, her fiancé continues to work in anticipation of
a family with Allie.
On the way back to the perfectly
renovated mansion Noah confesses that he is not, in fact, Amish even though he
dresses like he is, wears a beard like an Amish person, and builds wooden
furniture. He tells Allie that he’s dedicated his every waking moment since
that day on the Ferris wheel to her happiness, even at the cost of his own. As
it begins to pour Allie has the balls to drop a “why didn’t you write me” and
Noah eventually realizes that he should have used FedEx with a signature
requirement rather then relying upon regular mail.
Allie then makes the conscious decision
to cheat on her rich, understanding, good looking, tolerant, well-mannered,
doting, successful, non-possessive, supportive, giant ring-buying, sensitive
fiancé and ends up getting slammed against an antique cupboard while ripping
off Noah’s wet, Amish clothes and throwing them on the newly finished wood
floor where they undoubtedly soaked into the finish and ruined that section of
the wood before Noah ravishes her in the same bed that he ravished the war
widow in the day before. Details.
I’m certain that while Allie was painting
topless in the studio Noah built her with nothing more than his bare hands and
the labor of his undying love Noah was downstairs the following morning sanding
the water damage out of the floor in order restain and reseal it. Eventually,
her mother and her fiancé figure it out and we avoid the messy conversation
about betrayal, dishonesty, infidelity, and self-centeredness that was
appropriate. Instead, we get a watered down version of her rich, understanding,
good looking, tolerant, well-mannered, doting, successful, non-possessive,
supportive, giant ring-buying, and sensitive fiancé actually being—well,
understanding, tolerant, non-possessive, supportive, and sensitive about it
all.
We cut back to the modern day where we
see that James Garner has suffered a series of heart attacks while Allie has
drifted aimlessly in and out of interest in the story. We get a glimpse of
their children and grand children as the old Noah tells them that he’s not
leaving Allie alone. Eventually, she recognizes him for a couple of minutes and
they share a dance before she freaks out and has to be sedated. He ends up
sneaking into her hospital room and lying in bed with her and, after they agree
that their love and conquer all, they die side by side holding hands and are
discovered by the stereotypical overweight black nurse the following morning.
It’s at this point in the movie that
we’re all supposed to have a tear in our eye and a tissue in our hand reveling
in the presence of true, undying love. That’s not what ran through the cynical,
macho, uncompromisingly male side of my brain. Basically, The Notebook is
Forrest Gump except it’s not funny and Noah is not mentally
challenged—arguably.
The point of The Notebook is that no matter how much you love a woman she will inevitably go crazy and drive you to an early death. The entire movie is about a spoiled little rich girl who always got her way.
The point of The Notebook is that no matter how much you love a woman she will inevitably go crazy and drive you to an early death. The entire movie is about a spoiled little rich girl who always got her way.
Picture this movie:
A poor, attractive, hard working girl
from a single parent home with no money ventures out to the state fair where
she meets the man of her dreams who is from a well-to-do family vacationing for
the summer on the rich side of her town. They fall madly in love and spend a
summer sharing the simple things that make life worth living. Eventually, the
man’s parents send him away from the town and the woman is heartbroken. She
spends hours upon hours writing letters in hopes of his return. She pines for
him relentlessly seeking solace in no one and dedicating her entire existence to
the hope of his return.
He goes to school, lives the fast life
and beds dozens of women while living off his family money. He eventually falls
in love with another woman with family money who supports him and buys him
everything he wants. He accepts her affection and proposes a marriage of
convenience only to return to town years later and pray on the affections of
the dedicated woman. He lies to his friends and family and moves into the
woman’s house where she has kept a room for him despite his lack of contact. He
cheats on his fiancé and eventually calls of the wedding so he can be with the
other woman.
Not the same movie, is it?
Double Standard. If a woman does this
it’s considered “romance” or “undying love.” If a man does the same thing, he’s
a cheater and a louse. It’s along the same lines as when a group of women leave
their children and their husbands at home in order to get together to drink
pinot grigio and pick out sex toys at a friend’s house. Can you imagine having
a husband come home and announce that he was leaving for the evening to hang
out with his buddies and use some of the family money to buy a couple of sex
toys? I suppose that’s just the way the non-renovated plantation crumbles.
I’ll reluctantly admit that I found the
movie both interesting and thought provoking. I really did. Yes, it was sappy,
unrealistic from a practical point of view, cheesy at times, and very chick
oriented. However, the larger picture is that true love never dies and that
every woman wants to feel as loved and secure as Allie ultimately ended up
feeling—everything else be damned.
I get that and I’d venture a guess that
most men would too if forced to admit it. As the lonely war widow told Noah, “a
woman knows when a man looks into her eyes and sees someone else.” The same is
true for a man. And as the old Noah said to his children, “that's my sweetheart
in there. Wherever she is, that's where my home is.” That, too, is the truth.
The entire movie reminded me of an old Vern Gosdin song titled Chiseled in Stone. That song takes two and a half minutes, not two and a half hours. Download it
and listen. Let me know what you think.
Well, there it
is: My take on The Notebook. I hope you enjoyed it. Until next week, take
care of yourselves and remind someone that you love them. In the meantime, if
you need me, I’ll be growing a beard and remodeling my mansion singlehandedly.
That was my 2011 post.
You know, upon reflection the more I think about it, the more I think I just might be inextricably linked to this damn movie. Check out the dude Mrs. Some Guy and I saw in Napa Valley last year. I think Noah Calhoun was following us.
Oh. My. God. I'm James Marsden.
DP
That was my 2011 post.
You know, upon reflection the more I think about it, the more I think I just might be inextricably linked to this damn movie. Check out the dude Mrs. Some Guy and I saw in Napa Valley last year. I think Noah Calhoun was following us.
Oh. My. God. I'm James Marsden.
DP